Best Nutella Cookies You Can Order Online
Nutella and cookies are two of the best things in the world. Put them together and you get something amazing.
But not all Nutella cookies are the same. Some just add a tiny bit of Nutella flavor. Others stuff the whole cookie with real, gooey Nutella that oozes out when you take a bite. That's the kind we're talking about here.
What Makes a Good Nutella Cookie?
Real Nutella inside. Some cookies just use hazelnut flavoring or a tiny drizzle. The best ones use actual Nutella — a lot of it.
Soft and gooey. A Nutella cookie should be soft in the middle. The best ones are warm, melty, and gooey in the center.
Good chocolate. Nutella is made with cocoa and hazelnuts. So the chocolate in the cookie needs to be good too.
Baked fresh. Nutella cookies taste best when they're fresh. The best brands bake your cookies after you order them.
The Best Nutella Cookies Online
1. Star Cookies — Chocolate Chip Nutella Cookie
Star Cookies makes a huge 8 oz chocolate chip cookie stuffed with real Nutella. It's loaded with dark chocolate chips and milk chocolate chunks. Then the center is filled with gooey Nutella that melts out when you bite into it.
Every cookie is baked fresh in Orlando after you order. They also have a Nutella Double Chocolate version — deep, fudgy chocolate dough with milk chocolate and even more Nutella.
Price: $8 per cookie. Free shipping on boxes of 6+.
2. Star Cookies — Ferrero Rocher Cookie
If you love Nutella, you'll love this one too. It's a chocolate cookie stuffed with a whole Ferrero Rocher candy, Nutella, and crushed hazelnuts. Same deal — 8 oz, baked fresh, shipped fast.
3. Crumbl — Nutella Cookie (Rotating)
Crumbl has done Nutella cookies a few times on their rotating menu. When they have it, it's good. But you can't always get it. Their menu changes every week.
4. Insomnia Cookies
Insomnia Cookies delivers warm cookies late at night. They've had Nutella options on their menu. Great for late-night cravings if you're in their delivery area.
How to Eat a Nutella Cookie
Warm it up. Pop it in the microwave for 10-15 seconds. The Nutella melts and gets gooey again. Game changer.
Add ice cream. Put a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top of a warm Nutella cookie. The hot and cold combo is unreal.
Eat it slow. These cookies are rich. Take your time.
The Bottom Line
The best Nutella cookies you can order online are the ones that use real Nutella, bake fresh to order, and ship fast.
Star Cookies has three different Nutella flavors to choose from. Build your own box at starcookiesorl.com.