Star Cookies is an Orlando based bakery making fresh stuffed cookies, shipped to you. If you are looking for thick New York style cookies with a filled center, that is what we do.
What is a stuffed cookie?
A stuffed cookie is a thick cookie with a filling sealed inside the center. When you break one open, the filling is exposed in the middle rather than mixed through the dough. They are noticeably heavier and taller than a standard bakery cookie, because you need that thickness to hold a filling without it leaking.
The style comes out of New York, where oversized thick cookies became the standard. That is why you often see them called New York style cookies.
What flavors can you get?
Our core flavors include Ferrero Rocher, Dubai Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Nutella, Pistachio, Cookies N Cream, Coconut Raffaello, OG Chocolate Chip, and Lemon Pie. We rotate seasonal flavors alongside the core lineup throughout the year, so check the shop for what is available right now.
Ferrero Rocher is our best seller. Dubai Chocolate is the one people ask about most. If you are ordering for a group and cannot decide, Chocolate Chip Nutella is the safest pick.
Do you deliver cookies in Orlando?
We ship orders rather than doing local delivery. Your cookies arrive packaged and stay fresh for up to a week sealed, so shipping does not cost you freshness the way it might with a standard bakery cookie.
What should you look for in a good stuffed cookie?
- Weight. A real stuffed cookie is heavy. If it feels like a normal cookie, there is not much inside it.
- A visible filling. Break it in half. You should see a distinct center, not just swirls in the dough.
- Real ingredients. Real butter and actual chocolate make a noticeable difference against cheaper substitutes.
- Small batch. Mass produced cookies lose the soft center that makes the style work.
How should you eat them?
Warm. Preheat your oven to 350°F and heat for 3 to 5 minutes, or microwave for 12 to 15 seconds. Room temperature is fine too if that is your preference. Instructions come inside every box in English and Spanish.
Are stuffed cookies good for gifts and events?
They work well for birthdays, corporate gifts, and party favors because the size makes each cookie feel like a full dessert rather than a snack. A box of twelve covers a small gathering on its own. Order a few days ahead of your date so shipping has time to land.
Frequently asked questions
How long do the cookies stay fresh?
Up to 1 week sealed in their packaging at room temperature, and up to 4 weeks in the freezer.
Do the cookies need to be warmed?
They are better warm, but it is optional.
What is the most popular flavor?
Ferrero Rocher, by a clear margin. Dubai Chocolate is close behind and climbing.
Do you have seasonal flavors?
Yes. We rotate seasonal flavors alongside the core lineup throughout the year.
Where are the cookies made?
In the Orlando area, in small batches rather than mass produced.