Ferrero Rocher is our best selling cookie flavor, followed by Dubai Chocolate, Chocolate Chip Nutella, Pistachio, and Cookies N Cream. That ranking comes from our own order data, not from a guess about what sounds popular.
One thing to know before you read the list: we run a core lineup year round and rotate seasonal flavors alongside it. The ranking below covers our core flavors. Seasonal ones come and go, so check the shop for what is available right now.
Our best selling cookie flavors, ranked
- Ferrero Rocher. Hazelnut and chocolate. The most ordered flavor we make, by a clear margin.
- Dubai Chocolate. Pistachio cream with crispy kataifi. Newer than most of our lineup and already near the top.
- Chocolate Chip Nutella. The safe pick. If you are ordering for a group and do not know their tastes, this is the one.
- Pistachio. Straight pistachio cream, no chocolate competing with it.
- Cookies N Cream. Cookies and cream filling in a cookie. Consistently in our top five.
- Coconut Raffaello. Coconut and white chocolate. Quieter than the top five but has a loyal following.
- OG Chocolate Chip. The classic, no filling gimmicks.
- Lemon Pie. The top pick for people who do not want chocolate.
What is the most popular cookie flavor overall?
Across the industry, chocolate chip is still the most popular cookie flavor by volume. But in the stuffed cookie category specifically, nut based fillings win. Hazelnut and pistachio consistently outsell plain chocolate in our shop, which is the opposite of what happens with standard cookies.
Our own numbers show this clearly. Ferrero Rocher, Dubai Chocolate, and Pistachio are all nut forward, and all three outsell our plain chocolate chip.
Which flavor should you order first?
If you like hazelnut, start with Ferrero Rocher. If you have been seeing Dubai chocolate everywhere and want to know what the fuss is about, order that. If you are buying for other people and playing it safe, Chocolate Chip Nutella is the one nobody dislikes.
Which flavors are best for a group?
Mix nut based and chocolate based. A box that is all pistachio will please people who love pistachio and disappoint everyone else. Two or three chocolate flavors plus one or two nut flavors covers most preferences.
Frequently asked questions
Do you rotate flavors?
Yes. Our core lineup stays consistent year round and we run seasonal flavors alongside it. Some of our strongest sellers have been seasonal, so it is worth checking the shop rather than assuming what is listed here is everything.
What is your newest flavor?
Dubai Chocolate is one of the more recent additions and it moved into our top three quickly.
Which flavor is least sweet?
Pistachio. The filling is nut forward rather than sugar forward, so it reads less sweet than the chocolate based options.
Will a seasonal flavor come back?
Often, yes. Seasonal flavors rotate rather than disappear permanently.