NY Style Cookies โ€” Build Your Box ๐Ÿช

2012 reviews

Build Your Box in 3 Steps

Step 1:ย Choose your box size

Step 2:ย Pick your favorite flavors

Step 3:ย We bake them fresh and send them straight to you in less than 48 hours

NY Style Cookies โ€” Build Your Box ๐Ÿช
Product Description

Thick, soft, and stuffed with flavor โ€” Star Cookies are handcrafted in small batches using real ingredients.

Each cookie is baked fresh to order, sealed for freshness, and delivered in less than 48 hours.

Crispy on the outside, rich on the inside, and made to impress with every bite.

What Makes Us Different
  • Baked fresh, never mass-produced
  • Made with real butter, eggs, and chocolate
  • Ships fast โ€” less than 48 hours after baking
  • No preservatives or artificial flavors
  • Thick, soft, and gooey texture you wonโ€™t find anywhere else
Ingredients

Flour, butter, eggs, sugar, brown sugar, chocolate chips, vanilla extract, baking powder, and a pinch of salt.

(Ingredients may vary slightly depending on flavor.)

10,000+ cookies baked & delivered

100% Satisfaction Guarantee

Ships in less than 48 hours, Monโ€“Fri

FRESH

Premium cookies

THE BEST COOKIE EVER

Once you start, you can't stop

Over 10,000+ Cookies Made

& over 2,500+ happy customers & don't just take our word for it....

Our Promise

We bake every cookie to impress. If you donโ€™t love it, weโ€™ll make it right. No questions asked.

Us Vs. Them

See the difference between cookies made with care โ€” and cookies made by evil corporate

 
Star Cookies
Big Evil Cookie Brands
Clean ingredients
Baked Fresh
Preservatives
Hand made

Frequently asked questions

What makes Star Cookies different?

We donโ€™t bake for the masses โ€” every cookie is handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients and baked to perfection. No shortcuts, no preservatives, ever.

How big are your cookies?

Our cookies are massive โ€” around 6 oz each, with a crispy edge, soft center, and generous fillings in every bite. Theyโ€™re made to impress, not just satis

What ingredients do you use?

Only high-quality, carefully sourced ingredients โ€” real butter, the best chocolate, cage-free eggs, and premium nuts. We believe quality starts with what goes inside.

When will my order ship?

All cookies are baked fresh to order and ship in less than 48 hours (Monโ€“Fri). Every box leaves our kitchen at peak freshness.

How long do the cookies stay fresh?

Our cookies stay fresh for up to 7 days at room temperature. Warm them for a few seconds to bring back that just-baked texture.

What if I donโ€™t love my cookies?

We stand behind every batch. If you donโ€™t love them, weโ€™ll make it right โ€” no questions asked.